Composite Decking vs. Pressure Treated Wood Decking

Composite decking and pressure treated wood decking have their respective benefits and admirers. Choosing between the two of these popular options starts with evaluating the needs of individual consumers.

In terms of warranties, composite decking often has a 25-year warranty concerning. While 25-years represents a long period of use, fading may even begin after the initial installation of this material. The process is slow, yes, but it may require replacing one or more of the topping boards to avoid seeing this eventually drastic shift in color. On the other hand, the new boards will fade and assume the same color as the original boards.

Composite decking is, however, a convenient solution for homeowners who want a durable and relatively maintenance-free brand of material. For example: composite decking does not rot, nor does it require painting, staining or sealing. Once installed, it essentially takes care of itself. But that easy maintenance does come at the expense of wear and tea; composite decking is not scratch proof. Sanding will not remove scratches or other troublesome blemishes.

Pressure treated wood decking has its own share of strengths and weaknesses, too. A pressure treated deck has a naturally attractive appearance, which can be preserved with a semi translucent sealer or enhanced with a solid stain to match a wide variety of colors. And, unlike composite decking and the risk of irreversible scratching, pressure treated wood decking can be sanded and sealed again to match the overall look-and-feel of the surrounding material. Or, if more work needs to be done, other boards can be replaced as well.

At the same time, pressure treated wood decking typically involves considerably more maintenance than composite decking. Warranties for pressure treated wood decking can be up to 10 years less than those offered for composite decking. Specifically, pressure treated wood decking requires an effective power washing at least every three years. Without such care and the use of a strong sealer, pressure treated wood decking may dry out, crack or rot. Hence the importance of vigilant oversight: without this attention to detail, a pressure treated wood deck may not provide the longevity consumers want.

Depending on the circumstances and expectations of each consumer, composite decking and pressure treated wood decking enjoy their advantages and weakness. If convenience is a supreme consideration, then composite decking may be a smart choice. Conversely, pressure treated wood decking may be a better option for people who want materials that maintain their natural beauty. Each case is different, so get the facts before making a decision.